What I’ve Watched: Ghost in the Shell

past-projections-1421869

Ghost in the Shell (live action) came out in 2017 and just released on DVD/Blue-Ray.

Brief Summary:

For those not familiar with anime or anything that is awesome, then you probably don’t realize that this movie is based on a famous anime/manga series. In the near future, humans are routinely “upgraded” via cyber enhancements (arms, faces, bodies, mind, all that jazz). But the next step is creating a full-blown cyborg with a human mind. Enter Major. She is the first of her kind, and becomes a sort of badass counter-terrorism cop. Until she learns more and more about her past. And then all hell breaks loose because robots don’t know how to stop when on a warpath of human vengeance.

What works:

Boy howdy is this film gorgeous to look at! The story takes place in a metropolis and advertising has gone above and beyond our current means. Giant holograms show the newest products. It is simply beautiful to look at. This film really fills this world with gorgeous imagery that James Cameron would rival. This is really the star of the movie.

The theory of self is prevalent and I think it works. Contrary to many complaints this movie received prior to release (from Westernizing a classic Eastern series, whitewashing, etc.) I thought this movie maintained the base element of the GitS story. This is about a cyborg with a human brain, but no memory of her past. A good story begs the questions of why me? Who am I? And I think this movie did a good job showing this (though there could have been more additions to it to make it truly pop).

Scarlett Johansson was great. I don’t care about the whitewashing aspect (though I get it from some ends), she was the Major in my mind. Take out the fact she is white, and you have the perfect actress for this role. If you have seen the anime, then you know that Major is stoic, calm, kick-ass, holds-no bar and slightly humorous. This is what we have come to expect from ScarJo. I thought she perfectly captured the Major.

The rest of the cast was spot on. I loved the guy who played Batou and obviously the Chief was fantastic. Him even speaking Japanese was a good way of balancing this world. He was also a bad ass m’effer if you catch my meaning.

What doesn’t work:

While I loved the basic plot and all the action scenes, I felt like there were times the movie just plodded along. I think the director/writers wanted to walk the line between true cyberpunk and action that they should have just chosen one side. This is where the anime completely outshines the live-action movie. Pick one and go with it.

Along those same lines, I think the backstory was a bit meh. I think they should have weaved more in with the action and thus going with the more cyberpunk aspect of the two. Major is completely complex, as well as cybergentics in general that they didn’t do enough to highlight that.

Pre-conceived notions. What I mean is that this movie got so much criticism before it even got released. From the whitewashing conundrum to the fact this is based on a beloved anime/manga, too many people panned this movie. And I think that played a part in this movie not working. Sure the director, actors, anime creator all weighed in on it, but I think subconsciously that took away from what truly could have been amazing. Diehard fans will always bitch about the sanctity of their favorite works (myself included!) but I think the directors didn’t have the guts to use the source enough, thus going in a different direction which came out as an action movie with superhero-like tropes. It was always going to be tricky to appease the fans, but going for the masses was a misstep here and all the bad criticism before the movie even started filming had to have had some sway on the movie as a whole and I certainly felt it while watching it.

Rating:

3.5 out of 5

I truly enjoyed this movie. I really did. Though I wish it had the sense to go more closely to the source material because that is so rich in itself. The visuals are wow and I liked the actors chosen. Sure the dialogue was a bit blah, but all in all, I think this movie was good, not great, but good.